54 Sings Broadway’s Greatest Hits
54 Below, NYC, October 17, 2026
Reviewed by Jacqueline Parker

Is there any other way to describe an evening of music that begins with the three lovely angels from Kenya (triplets, actually) known as MOIPEI, than heavenly? Their voices melded together in a rousing opening of Cole Porter’s highly appropriate “Anything Goes” that made one ponder just how prescient he was with many of his lyrics, here nearly a century old. They were dressed in matching style, differentiated only by color.
Matthew Drinkwater was unusually expressive in his rendition of Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe’s “Come to Me, Bend to Me” from Brigadoon. It seemed such a real and heartfelt plea that I felt like rooting for him. If MOIPEI was heavenly, then Ryan Knowles’ version of “16 Tons” (Merle Travis), originally made popular by Tennessee Ernie Ford, came hellishly close to a growl.
Returning to the celestial theme, two performers were truly sublime in their song choices and deliveries: Ben Jones and William Michals. Jones took on two famous musical soliloquys, affecting a slight British accent when he portrayed Professor Higgins from My Fair Lady in “I’ve Grown Accustomed to Her Face” (Lerner/Loewe). One has perhaps become accustomed to the rather arch interpretation of this song by the original Higgins, Rex Harrison. Since he couldn’t really sing, he delivered the song in a speak/sing manner, which was effective at the time. Jones took the song a bit further, this time portraying an intellectual truly befuddled, and profoundly so, by this conundrum known as love. Jones ripped back the scrim covering the heart of this character in near tears at the end, but oh how wonderful it was to see Higgins in the full distress that only love can wreak.
Later in the evening he approached that grandaddy of them all, “Soliloquy” from Carousel (Richard Rodgers/Oscar Hammerstein II). Here he did the same thing, delving deeper into the heart of a man speaking to himself without pretense, yet revealing a deeper emotional connection to his conundrum. Jones held nothing back in the performance of these two numbers.
William Michals brought his extraordinary baritone to two songs from that golden era of Broadway musicals: “They Call the Wind Maria” from 1961’s Paint Your Wagon (Lerner/Loewe) and “The Impossible Dream” from 1965’s Man of La Mancha (Mitch Leigh/Joe Darion). Dorothy Parker once said upon being introduced to Orson Welles that “it was like meeting God without dying.” Hearing Michals deliver these two powerful numbers was like hearing God sing without dying. His rich sound invaded the heart and brought us back to the ‘60s and all the idealism that was seemingly rampant at the time.
Mark T. Evans as music director/pianist was superb, and kudos to that great champion of the Great American Songbook Scott Siegel (who created the series and serves as its host) for his work in keeping this music alive and vibrant.

