Claudine Cassan-Jellison
Am I Blue?
Don’t Tell Mama, NYC, June 27, 2026
Reviewed by Bart Greenberg

Photo by Melinda Tanner
Claudine Cassan-Jellison brought many emotions to the stage of Don’t Tell Mama, but despite the title of Am I Blue?, being blue was not a prominent one. Optimism, anger, compassion, and hope were all on full display. So was her excellent taste in songs; her charming singing voice contained echoes of Blossom Dearie, Estelle Parsons, and Katharine Hepburn, but she made it all her own using her powerful acting skills.
The center of the show was Cassan-Jellison’s interpretation of a variety of people she met as she worked as a telephone canvasser for the Democratic Party. These monologues brought to life an immigrant who was devoted to American baseball; an elderly lady of the South whose patriotism, family life, and religion were interwoven; and several more. Her creations, vivid and compassionate, moved the audience. Her mix of joy and cynicism gave the show a deep substance.
This isn’t to negate her fine delivery of some beautifully chosen and contrasting musical numbers such as “The House I Live In” (Earl Robinson/Lewis Allan) and “Blizzard of Lies” (Dave & Samantha Frishberg). Music director/pianist David Gaines, in collaboration with Ritt Henn on bass, provided sterling support throughout. The opening medley of “Be Optimistic” (Harold Spina/Walter Bullock) and “A Cockeyed Optimist” (Richard Rodgers/Oscar Hammerstein II) served to expose Cassan-Jellison’s true persona. “That’s Good, That’s Bad” (Mary Rodgers/Stephen Sondheim) was an example of her political views, and a dandy example of finding an obscure song that perfectly fits the moment. That may be one of the trademarks of expert director Barry Kleinbort.
By bringing the show to a close with Jason Robert Brown’s “HOPE” and with the very gentle “Goodnight, New York” (Julie Gold), Cassan-Jellison gave a warm and optimistic ending to her sometimes problematic view of politics today. It was a lovely way to end this powerful program. Bravo to all involved.

