Seth Christenfeld
Life, the Universe, and Everything:
The Seth Christenfeld 42nd (and a half) Birthday Spectacular
54 Below, NYC, April 21, 2025
Reviewed by Jacqueline Parker

All that was missing was the cake, or at least a cupcake since this was not a full birthday celebration. It is rare to be taken by surprise in such a delightful way in the cabaret world. Seth Christenfeld, former literary manager for the York Theatre Company, is also an accomplished lyricist. He is known and deservedly respected for his extensive and insightful knowledge of musical theater, and the surprise lay in the fact that he is also quite an accomplished lyricist and providing the words for all but one of the songs that were presented in this show. (The composers are indicated in the parenthesis after each song title.)
This fact was evident from the beginning of the evening, when Apryl Arden began the party with “Aria for a Vengeful Soprano” (James Ballard). Her rich and powerful voice suddenly led into the lyric “Are You scr**ing her?,” a most unlikely phrase from such a beautiful voice. She returned later in the program to join Doug Shapiro and Sam Balzac in “March of the Critics” (Eric Grunin), which included a pithy lyric about a hyphen-lacking dash. Christenfeld’s contributions to the evening were peppered with such clever double entendres, reminiscent of a young Lorenz Hart or even Cole Porter.
Shapiro returned to the stage with “Listen to Me Less” (Nora Terzo) for which Christenfeld provided a suitably clever ending. There were touching and tender songs as well. Sam Simahk delivered “Lake Michigan Blue” (James Ballard) most effectively as a sentimental ballad. Ann Harada lent her stellar comedic chops to “It’s Sunny” (Amy Englehardt) and was duly rewarded with plentiful applause.
There was a loving tribute to composer and lyricist William Finn who died earlier in the month and had taught and garnered the respect and admiration of many of the performers. The musicians supporting this venture were members of The Badass All-B Band, an appropriately off-beat name for a group whose names all begin with B—James Ballard was busy with music direction and supervision as well as playing piano and trumpet; Will Buck shared piano duties on three of the songs; with Alec Berlin (guitar); Wes Bourland bass); and Brooke Trumm (drums). The other singers for the show were Sam Balzak, Aleandra de Suze, Jovan E’Sean, Lyda Jade Harlan, Alyse Alan Louis, Jesse Manocherian, Zal Owen, and Senna Prasatthong. The other composers represented in the show were Christiana Cole, Will Buck, and Paolo K Tiról.
Michael Winther brought the evening to a close with the upbeat “This Too Shall Pass” (Brendan Milburn) and spread the joy by encouraging us to clap along. Christenfeld returned to the stage to thank his audience and announced that he had been “reorganized out of a job,” but had responded to this change by writing the song “Here’s to New Adventures.” This was an evening of fun and frivolity; the love and respect all performers had for Christenfeld was palpable. Throw mine in as well!