The Kleinbort Collection:
The Songs of Barry Kleinbort
Birdland, NYC, March 3, 2025
Reviewed by Jacqueline Parker
Photos by Maryann Lopinto
Imagine that you have been given a beautiful candy box, but instead of chocolates, inside you find nuggets of gold. That was the experience at Birdland where Jamie deRoy and cast presented the music and lyrics of Barry Kleinbort. While he is known for directing some of the most successful cabarets shows Kleinbort’s other talent is songwriting, for which he has won numerous awards.
The lineup of superlative talent who brought these songs to life included (in alphabetical order) Loni Ackerman, Lewis Cleale, Lorna Dallas, Gregg Edelman, Penny Fuller, Eric Michael Gillett, Judy Kaye, Nicolas King, Karen Mason, Gretchen Reinhagen, Caroline Roelands, and Haley Swindal. The piano duties were shared by the well-known music directors Christopher Denny, Paul Greenwood, and David Gaines; Tom Hubbard accompanied them all on bass. With all this expertise on one stage, a memorable evening was in store for the audience.

Kleibort is known for his special material, and Judy Kaye showed us how special it is when she got the evening started with “I Get Around,” a list song that was hilarious and perfectly suited to Kaye’s talents. Lewis Cleale and Haley Swindal changed the pace with “To Be Wanted” and “Ev’ryone Needs Someone,” two tender songs that warmed our hearts. Karen Mason’s ability to infuse vulnerability and honesty into her delivery made “The Kindest Man” almost a private confession that one felt privileged to overhear.

A surprise was the two numbers that qualify as great NYC songs: “Big City Rhythm” and “Everything is Waiting for Me.” Both of them captured that feeling of excitement that is so uniquely New York, made even more thrilling by Nicolas King’s personal enthusiasm. Eric Michael Gillett added his own magic to “I Belong,” which captured the wonder and gratitude that come with realizing that you have landed where you were meant to be—in New York City!

One of the most difficult songs of the evening, and certainly one of Kleinbort’s most ambitious, was “A Sondheim Song.” This devilishly clever tune was put in the capable hands of Gillett, and he delivered it beautifully, making sure every sly reference was clear and appreciated.

Kleibort shared the credit for “Time” with Joseph Thalken, who wrote the music. Again, Mason brought her technical prowess to this song, which, when paired with her ability to totally open her heart to her audience, made the show one of the most exciting and unforgettable evenings in cabaret.