Backstage Babble
Beyond the Walls of Joe Allen Restaurant
54 Below, NYC, February 19, 2025
Reviewed by Jacqueline Parker
Photos by Maryann Lopinto

Charles Kirsch, creator of the podcast Backstage Babble, worked his magic again at 54 Below, this time by paying tribute to the shows whose posters line the wall of Joe Allen’s Restaurant in NYC. This is not a wall of winners; it’s a wall of flops. Kirsch assembled cast members from these shows who shared reminiscences and sang a number or two from the show they appeared. He was joined in this venture by music director/pianist Michael Lavine. In addition to being its producer, Kirsch also was the host of this tribute to a baker’s dozen of mostly forgotten musicals.
Alma Cuervo sang “Nothing Really Happened” (Craig Carnelia, from Is There Life After High School) so tenderly that it was almost impossible not to be drawn back into memories of one’s own high school days. Quintessential showman Lee Roy Reams made Lorelei come alive again with his version of “I Won’t Let You Get Away” (Jule Styne/Betty Comden & Adolph Green), and with his many stories about its star Carol Channing and its composer Jule Styne.

Onward Victoria was a 1980 musical about Victoria Woodhull, a suffragette who ran for U.S. president in 1872. The original star, Jill Eikenberry, delivered a touching rendition of “Another Life” (Keith Hermann/Charlotte Anker & Irene Rosenberg), which beautifully laments the end of the fictional romance between Woodhull and Henry Ward Beecher.

Charles Busch talked about House of Flowers and insightfully observed that other than West Side Story, this show had the greatest collection of genius theatrical talent assembled for its creation. He then sang a number from that show that had been on an early Streisand album: “Don’t Like Goodbyes” (Harold Arlen/Truman Capote). In a performance as moving as the earlier version had been, Busch captured all the heartbreak in the song’s lyric.

The show concluded when Danielle Chambers, daughter of Leslie Uggams, sang a medley of songs from her mother’s second Broadway show Her First Roman (Ervin M. Drake). With Uggams in the audience, this segment was pure magic.
Throughout this show of music many had never heard—or even heard of—before, one had to feel grateful that these songs were being kept alive in some way. It was indeed comforting to know that Kirsch, who is still a teenager, has a passion for the music we all cherish.
Fans of Charles Kirsch, as well as of Broadway musicals, should know that the next venture is 54 Sings Coco. Coco was the 1969 musical about Coco Chanel that starred Katharine Hepburn with music by André Previn and lyrics by Alan Jay Lerner.