The Yale Whiffenpoofs
54 Below, NYC, February 5, 2005,
Reviewed by Jacqueline Parker
Like a cool breeze on a hot summer afternoon—or, more seasonally accurate, like a mug of hot chocolate to welcome you in from the cold—The Yale Whiffenpoofs strode confidently onto the stage at 54 Below and charmed an appreciative audience with their mastery of a cappella singing. Started in 1909, they are the world’s oldest and best-known collegiate a cappella group. Every year, 14 senior Yale students are selected to join this prestigious group, whose alumni include Cole Porter (class of 1913). Incidentally, Porter wrote the Yale Fight Song “Bulldog.”
The Whiffenppofs brought their youthful enthusiasm from New Haven and delivered a whose writers ranged from Jerome Kern to Paul Simon. Their youth was obvious and contrasted with the talent displayed by each of them. They were, individually and collectively, a refreshing change of pace from the typical cabaret show.
Most appealing was their take on “All the Things You Are” (Kern/Oscar Hammerstein II) from Very Warm for May (1939). Performed as originally intended, this song is done by two couples (one almost aghost couple), and they harmonize beautifully. The Whiffenpoofs came as close to the original version as possible, and their expert harmonizing was enthralling.
Each member of the group had a solo, and most often they were supported by the others as their back-up singers. The entire program was polished and at times surprising. Their “Midnight Train to Georgia” (Jim Weatherly) was enhanced by a charming bit of choreography that was so surprising on such a small stage already fully populated. There were other movements, such as finger snapping, that kept this hip group from having any hint of “choir” about them. Their interpretations of “Goodbye, Yellow Brick Road” (Elton John/Bernie Taupin) and “The Boxer” (Simon) were moving and in complete contrast to the playfulness they displayed earlier in the program.
The show closed with “The Whiffenpoof Song,” which they delivered with great reverence as we all raised our glasses and sang along with them. Let’s hope next time around they include the aforementioned Porter song, which was conspicuous by its absence.