Songbook Sundays
Heart and Soul and Hoagy Carmichael
Hosted and curated by
Deborah Grace Winer
Featuring
Christine Andreas, Kenita Miller, and Christian Wiggs
Dizzy’s Club, NYC, October 13, 2024
Reviewed by Jacqueline Parker

Photo: Magda Katz
A packed room at Dizzy’s enjoyed the approaching sunset and the Central Park trees eager to shed their springtime green while they listened to some of Hoagy Carmichael’s most beloved standards. Christine Andreas set the tone with “In the Cool, Cool, Cool of the Evening” (Johnny Mercer lyricist).

Photo: Magda Katz
Sharing the stage with her were Kenita Miller and Christian Wiggs, who brought their own brands of jazzy interpretation to each number. Wiggs had his way with “Two Sleepy People” (Frank Loesser lyricist) and then delivered one of Carmichael’s most haunting tunes “Skylark” (Mercer), and his deep baritone made it even more so.

Photo: Magda Katz
Miller brought her powerful voice to “How Little We Know” (Mercer) with such authority that one had to ponder just how little we do know. “Stardust” (Mitchell Parish, lyricist) is the most recorded of all of Carmichael’s songs, and it must be a daunting task for a singer to tackle it with ingenuity. But Miller did just that and brought out the poignancy of those dreamy words.

Photo: Magda Katz
In a quintessential example of how Andreas can pierce a listener’s heart with the emotional impact of her delivery, she rendered “I Get Along Without You Very Well (Except Sometimes)” (Carmichael and Jane Brown Thompson,lyricists) with all the sincere honesty of a young girl dealing with her first heartbreak. Her voice was sweet yet strong, and she was achingly tender and sad, which made the palpability of the pain all the more real. She showed a bit of undisguised coquettishness there as well. She looked as young and beautiful as she did when I first heard her several decades ago. She carried the song to a new height.
And what’s a Hoagy Carmichael show without “Heart and Soul?” The band bypassed Frank Loesser’s lyrics and added their own special magic to the evening with a wordless interpretation of that classic. Hats off to Ted Rosenthal as music director/pianist, Christian X.M. McGhee on drums, Jayla Chee on bass, and Sarah Hanahan on saxophone.
Andreas made “Lazy River” (Sidney Arodin, lyricist) swing just enough to make it fit appropriately into a jazz venue like Dizzy’s. It brought to mind the other river tune that Audrey Hepburn made so memorable in Breakfast at Tiffany’s: “Moon River” (Henry Mancini/Mercer). The singers and musicians brought the program to a swinging conclusion when they joined in on a reprise of “Lazy River” and then added some scat.
This series, hosted and curated by Deborah Grace Winer, is always a worthwhile way to spend an hour or so. Her commentary is always interesting and appreciated and offers tidbits of information one would have to search for to find. She’s done that homework for the audience, and she deserves an A+ for doing it.
Winer should be applauded for honoring the American Songbook, which is one of the greatest gifts this country has given to the world. Her efforts to delight audiences with these treasured events, which feature superb selections of material and performers, are a panacea in these troubling times. Don’t miss the next offering, which pays tribute to that other Indiana tunesmith, Cole Porter, on December 8. Hope to see you there!